News in English
Overall rating: Your rating:
Rating 0.0 with 0 votes Rate this news article!
The Infrastructure Agency chose the maker of the scale model in a public tender. Foto: BoBo


Second Rail scale model: An erroneous Excel calculation was to blame for the selection of a much more expensive model

Based on the public tender criteria, a cheaper option should have been chosen
13. March 2018 ob 18:59
Ljubljana - MMC RTV SLO

The Ministry of Infrastructure chose a more expensive option for the scale model of the proposed Second Rail track because of an error in Excel tables, explained Damir Topolko, the head of the Directorate for Infrastructure.

Prime Minister Miro Cerar unveiled the scale model of the Second Rail project last week in Koper. The scale model was part of a multimedia presentation showing the construction and the placement of the new rail link.

The Infrastructure Agency chose the maker of the scale model in a public tender. The winning bid, worth just over 133,000 euros, came from the company Art Rebel 9. However, it was later revealed that another bid, worth less than 61,000 euros, had been submitted by a company known as RPS.

In the public tender, the price was an important criterion (worth 100 out of 200 possible points). However, as can be seen from the result of the tender, the more expensive model got the maximum number of points, while the less expensive bid received fewer points. Supposedly, the more expensive model was more complete, and it included a multimedia presentation. That's why it received more points in the second part than its cheaper competitor (Art Rebel received 68 points, whereas RPS received 43). Still, based on the tender criteria, the cheaper model should have been chosen because of the 70,000-euro difference. But RPS never appealed the decision.

A computing error to blame
But why was the more expensive model chosen? According to the Infrastructure Agency, a review of the documentation revealed an error.

"Our commission used an Excel calculation as the basis on which to evaluate the tenders. However, the formulas for this tender were not updated in the file. That's how the error occurred," explained the head of the Infrastructure Agency Damir Topolko, whose signature was on the public order.

Topolko added that the Infrastructure Agency processes many public tenders, some 260 a year. The tenders are the responsibility of committees that prepare the reports; those reports are then reviewed before the head of the agency confirms them.

Gregor Cerar; translated by J. B.
TV & Radio
NEWS DEUTSCH 16. 3. 2018 00:03:41, 16.03.2018
News in English 16.03.2018 00:03:53, 16.03.2018
News in English 15.03.2018 00:03:37, 15.03.2018
NEWS DEUTSCH 15.03.2018 00:03:28, 15.03.2018
NEWS ENGLISH, 14.03.2018 00:03:02, 14.03.2018
NEWS DEUTSCH 14. 3. 2018 00:03:52, 14.03.2018
NEWS ENGLISH, 13.03.2018 00:03:37, 13.03.2018
DEUTSCHE NEWS 13.3.2018 00:03:49, 13.03.2018
News in English 12.03.2018 00:03:17, 12.03.2018
NEWS DEUTSCH 12. 3. 2018 00:03:43, 12.03.2018
News in English 11.03.2018 00:03:49, 11.03.2018
DEUTSCHE NEWS 11.3.2018 00:03:56, 11.03.2018
News in English 10.03.2018 00:03:34, 10.03.2018
NEWS DEUTSCH 00:02:42, 10.03.2018
Highlights of the week 00:05:56, 10.03.2018
News in English 09.03.2018 00:03:19, 09.03.2018
News Deutsch 9.3.2018 00:03:31, 09.03.2018
Brexit implications 00:24:17, 09.03.2018
English News 8.3 00:02:11, 08.03.2018